As a self-proclaimed all-inclusive resort nut, I’ve had the opportunity to experience a wide range of vacation options. While all-inclusive resorts offer convenience, comfort, and quality, non-all-inclusive resorts can offer unique and unforgettable experiences.
Let’s explore the pros and cons of all-inclusive vs a la carte resorts and help you decide on your next vacation.
All-Inclusive vs Not all-Inclusive Resorts – Key Differences
Here are key differences between an all-inclusive resort and a non-all-inclusive resort to compare both options:
Room Features and Types of Rooms
All-inclusive resorts generally provide a package deal that includes accommodations, food, drinks, room service, and entertainment. That being said, the quality of the room and amenities may vary based on the package price.
Non-all-inclusive resorts typically offer a wider variety of room options, ranging from basic to luxurious, and guests have the option to pay for food, drinks, and activities separately.
Base Rate
The cost of an all-inclusive hotel varies depending on the resort’s location and level of luxury but generally ranges from $200 to $600 per day. Conversely, non-all-inclusive resorts tend to have a lower base rate than all-inclusive resorts.
It’s important to consider additional expenses such as meals, drinks, and activities when comparing the two options. While all-inclusive resorts may seem more costly initially, they can offer more value depending on the traveler’s preferences and budget.
Services
All-inclusive resorts typically provide a broad range of services and amenities that are included in the price of the stay, such as meals, drinks, activities, and even spa treatments and excursions. This can make it easier to stick to a budget and enjoy a diverse set of experiences without worrying about extra expenses.
Some travelers may feel that all-inclusive resorts lack local culture and may feel isolated from the surrounding area. In contrast, non-all-inclusive resorts offer many of the same services and amenities but at an extra cost.
What’s Included
Luxury all-inclusive resorts generally bundle lodging, buffet, drinks (including alcoholic beverages), non-motorized water sports, restaurant activities, and staff tips and taxes into their package price. Some all-inclusive resorts may also offer extra benefits like fitness centers, wellness classes, Wi-Fi, beach access, loyalty programs, and room upgrades.
You can find most of these options in a non-all-inclusive resort as well. But, the difference between these two is that while all costs are included in the former, you’ll need to pay extra money to enjoy additional services in the latter.
Food Quality and Pricing
All-inclusive resorts usually offer unlimited food and drinks as part of their pricing, whereas non-inclusive resorts require guests to pay for each meal. The food quality can vary at both types of resorts, but all-inclusive resorts tend to provide a broader range of dining options.
While dining expenses at non-inclusive resorts can quickly add up – with dinner prices often ranging from $75 to $100 for two people.
Tipping
Tipping at resorts is not mandatory, but it is generally expected for good service. The amount to tip may vary depending on the hotel and location, but a general rule of thumb is to budget around $150 (or the local currency equivalent) in tips for a one-week stay.
It’s recommended to have $20 in singles on hand to make tipping accessible whenever it’s needed. It’s important to remember that tipping amounts are not fixed and may vary depending on the level of service received.
Entertainment
While entertainment is usually included in the price of an all-inclusive stay, the quality of the entertainment offered may not always meet expectations. Some all-inclusive resorts offer a wide variety of entertainment options, such as live music, shows, and activities, while others may have limited options.
When it comes to non-all-inclusive resorts, the cost of entertainment is not included in the price of the stay. This means you can select an activity, depending on your preferences, and then pay for it accordingly!
Excursions
All-inclusive resorts usually have a variety of excursions and activities available to guests, but not all of them may be included in the price of the stay. Depending on the resort, excursions may be offered as part of a package deal or may require an additional fee.
While non-all-inclusive resorts may offer more personalized experiences and greater flexibility in terms of excursions and dining options. Still, each activity and meal will need to be paid for separately.
Amenities
All-inclusive resorts usually have a nightly, per-person rate that covers a wide range of amenities, including swimming pools, non-motorized water sports, fitness centers, wellness classes, Wi-Fi, and beach access. For those interested in a more unique experience, some all-inclusive resorts also offer amenities like swim-up bars, unique restaurant concepts, and private beach dinners, enhancing the all-inclusive experience. Some all-inclusive resorts may require extra fees for spa treatments and off-site excursions.
In contrast, most amenities are excluded in non-all-inclusive resorts as they only charge for accommodations, with meals, drinks, and activities available for individual purchase. While all-inclusive resorts can offer a stress-free vacation, non-all-inclusive resorts may provide a more peaceful and relaxed atmosphere.
Overall Value
Are all-inclusive worth it, or should you opt for non-all-inclusive resorts? Well, all-inclusive resorts can offer guests a better restaurant ROI and value overall compared to non-all-inclusive resorts. This is because the pricing structure is usually on a per-person, per-night basis, which includes unlimited food, drinks, lodging, and additional services based on the resort’s offerings.
With this approach, guests can have a clear idea of the total cost of their vacation before they even arrive, and many major expenses, such as lodging, food, and activities, are already included in the price. In contrast, non-all-inclusive resorts may have lower upfront costs, but guests may end up spending more on food, drinks, and activities during their stay.
How to Decide?
Deciding between an all-inclusive or not all-inclusive resort ultimately boils down to your individual priorities and preferences. Although all-inclusive resorts provide convenience and assurance, they might be costlier and may offer fewer tailored experiences. Conversely, non-all-inclusive resorts may offer more customized experiences, but they can also be more expensive and require more planning!
